401(k) loan gold seen on Capitol Hill

Register now


NEW YORK Sat. Aug. 11, 2012 9:50 am EDT (Reuters) — Tod Ruble is trying to sell retirement plan insurance that employers say they do not want and their employees may not need.

But the Dallas-based veteran commercial real estate investor is not letting that stop him. Since late 2010, he has started a company, Custodia Financial, and spent more than $1 million pushing for legislation that would allow companies to automatically enroll employees who borrow from their 401(k) plans in insurance that could cost hundreds of dollars a year.

The idea of the Retirement Savings Security Act is to protect employees who borrow from their 401(k) retirement funds – and their beneficiaries – in the event that they die or become disabled, Ruble said. Custodia plans to add unemployment to that list.

The bill already has strong backing. It is sponsored by Texas Rep. Peter Sessions, the National Republican Congressional Committee chairman, and has bipartisan support from four co-sponsors: Reps Bruce Braley and Ruben Hinojosa, both Democrats, as well as Reps Tom Latham and Patrick Tiberi, both Republicans.

Solution in search of a problem?

Employers and 401(k) providers say the bill is simply a solution in search of a problem and would just be an added expense for employees. They cite U.S. Department of Labor data that shows in 2009 only $670 million of the $51.73 billion in 401(k) loans was in default. Custodia says the problem is actually much bigger because that number may not include all defaults.

“They have a product that they can’t sell so they want Congress to step in,” said Ed Ferrigno, vice president, Washington affairs, for the Plan Sponsor Council of America.

Ruble said he started Custodia because he saw 401(k) loan default as “a real issue that needed addressing.”

He said companies have told him that they want to offer 401(k) loan insurance but won’t do so until Congress passes legislation that says doing so will not put them in violation of their fiduciary duties. He would not say which companies he has spoken with.

Ruble has a lot riding on the bill. Custodia stands to make millions – even billions – of dollars if the measure passes and not just from collecting premiums. The firm has acquired the patents to the technology and implementation behind the 401(k) loan insurance it wants to offer, according to documents reviewed by Reuters. Other insurers would have to pay Custodia to use the patented process.

As of the end of 2011, 26.6% of employees had borrowed against their 401(k) assets, with an average loan balance of $7,923, according to Aon Hewitt.

If the bill is passed, employees could end up paying hundreds of dollars to insure money they owe themselves, said Judy Miller, director of retirement policy at the American Society of Pension Professionals and Actuaries.

Some employees might not realize they are being enrolled in and paying for the insurance, said Diann Howland, vice president, legislative affairs, at the American Benefits Council. “This is not good for plans or plan participants,” she said.

Bob Hunter, director of insurance for the Consumer Federation of America, is particularly concerned about the idea of auto-enrolling employees. “For Congress to make it automatic is a totally absurd way to buy insurance and it is totally inappropriate,” said Hunter, who was the Federal Insurance Administrator under President Jimmy Carter. “The default should be no insurance, not insurance.”

Custodia’s chief financial officer, Kevin Smart, estimates that on a $10,000 loan paid off over five years, the company’s insurance – with coverage for disability, death and unemployment – would cost about $1,048. For employees who did not default, that would result in less money being returned to their retirement savings account than was originally borrowed.

According to Aon Hewitt, fewer than 3% of employed borrowers defaulted on a 401(k) loan in 2011, compared with a 63% default rate among borrowers who lost their jobs.

Ruble said he started Custodia in 2010 for the sole purpose of passing the Retirement Savings Security Act so employers feel comfortable offering and auto-enrolling borrowers. “Employers would like to have certain legal certainties before they do this,” he said. “They need a nudge.”

He likens it to the time before the Pension Protection Act of 2006, which among other things said that employers who automatically enroll employees in their 401(k) plans would not be in violation of their fiduciary duties. Before the act, 19% of plans had auto-enroll features. Now 57% do.

For Custodia, the payoff of passing the legislation goes beyond insurance premiums. Through its affiliate Pentech LLC, the firm owns five patents that cover every step in offering, calculating, administering and collecting 401(k) loan insurance, according to documents reviewed by Reuters. Competitors would have to spend significant time developing their own process or license it from Custodia.

Retirement plan trade groups are concerned that despite their push against the bill, it may pass as an add-on to bigger, last-minute legislation at the end of the year. “We are worried that this may slip through and we won’t have time to stop it,” said Howland.

(Additional reporting by Suzanne Barlyn in New York; Editing by Jennifer Merritt, Walden Siew and Leslie Adler)

© 2011 Thomson Reuters. Click for Restrictions.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.