Zenefits has filed a motion to dismiss an anti-defamation lawsuit filed against it by payroll services giant ADP, continuing a heated row between the two companies that Zenefits says comes down to a a fight for “consumer choice.”

The dispute between the two companies ignited in June when ADP disabled Zenefits’ access to its systems for shared clients. Zenefits publicly decried the move, calling it “an anti-competitive fear tactic” and ADP fired back with an anti-defamation lawsuit accusing the HR tech firm of conducting “a manipulative and malicious public relations campaign, ignoring its own conduct, to defame ADP and drive away ADP clients.”

See also: Zenefits, ADP dispute heats up with defamation lawsuit

In court filings Monday and Tuesday, Zenefits said ADP “cannot establish a probability of success on the merits of these claims” that the HR tech company defamed ADP and unfairly damaged the payroll company’s business. Zenefits says the company’s public criticisms of ADP are permitted under California law and the U.S. Constitution. The company filed the motion to dismiss under California’s anti-SLAPP statute (strategic lawsuits against public participation.)

In the court filings, the HR tech company accuses ADP of trying to silence it and its CEO Parker Conrad about ADP’s “anti-competitive tactics.”

“We’re on the side of consumer choice and we’re not going to stop speaking out about that,” David Sacks, COO of Zenefits, said in televised comments about the lawsuit.

See also: Why Zenefits isn’t anti-broker

“ADP has been out there creating fear about us as a new market entrant and now they’re suing us for defamation. That’s highly ironic,” he said.

Dick Wolfe, senior director of corporate communication for ADP says, “ADP has a long history of partnering with third parties, including those who could be considered ‘competitors’. The notion that Zenefits was blocked to stifle such competition is simply wrong. Legal action against Zenefits was not undertaken lightly, and came only after ADP made attempts to resolve these issues directly and amicably with Zenefits. Those efforts were rebuffed and Zenefits embarked on a public campaign of false statements and outright defamation, which they have continued to engage in even after the filing of the lawsuit. ”

Client impact

In June, Zenefits CEO Parker Conrad said Zenefits clients are frustrated with the disabling of access to ADP’s payroll service system and some clients say they will drop ADP. Likewise, he said, Zenefits may lose a few customers, too, before the row is worked out.

He says Zenefits is helping current clients with a workaround to help them manually enter the data that Zenefits no longer has access to do.

Zenefits is also helping some clients switch to new payroll service providers.

Register or login for access to this item and much more

All Employee Benefit Adviser content is archived after seven days.

Community members receive:
  • All recent and archived articles
  • Conference offers and updates
  • A full menu of enewsletter options
  • Web seminars, white papers, ebooks

Don't have an account? Register for Free Unlimited Access